
Navigating DOL changes: considerations for employers and fiduciaries
Prabal Lakhanpal, senior vice president and Karin Landry, senior consultant and co-founder of Spring Consulting Group, look at the implications of a recent DOL decision to look at PTE procedures.
The US Department of Labor (DOL) has signaled plans to revisit the procedures governing prohibited transaction exemptions (PTEs) under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). The Department’s Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) included a proposal in its 2026 regulatory agenda to update exemption procedures, reduce regulatory burdens and improve the application process (RIN 1210-AC42).
Although specific changes have not been proposed, the agency identified August 2026 as the target date for a proposed rule. No proposed rule had been published as of this writing.
Potential changes could affect plan sponsors, fiduciaries, service providers and employers using affiliated entities, such as captive insurance companies, to fund benefits. Because captive arrangements can generate annual savings of 10% to 15%, a more efficient exemption process could create additional opportunities for employers while reinforcing the importance of fiduciary governance.
For employers considering captive-funded benefits, understanding the exemption process, including its timeline, costs and documentation requirements, is an important part of evaluating feasibility.
Understanding prohibited transaction exemptions
ERISA establishes fiduciary standards to protect retirement plan participants and beneficiaries. It generally prohibits transactions between a plan and a “party in interest,” including the plan sponsor, affiliated entities, fiduciaries and service providers to help prevent conflicts of interest.
The DOL may grant relief from certain prohibited transaction restrictions when an arrangement meets three criteria: It must be:
1.Administratively feasible.
2.In the interests of plan beneficiaries.
3.Protect beneficiary and participants’ rights.
Exemptions allow otherwise prohibited transactions when applicants demonstrate appropriate safeguards and satisfy applicable conditions.
Relief may take several forms:
Individual exemptions: Granted to a specific applicant for a particular transaction.
Class exemptions: Available to organisations meeting the conditions of an established exemption.
Statutory exemptions: Established directly by Congress in ERISA.
EXPRO exemptions, authorised under PTE 96-62, offer an expedited pathway for transactions substantially similar to previously approved exemptions, generally requiring two individual exemptions granted within the preceding five years.
Many exemptions also require ongoing oversight, documentation and independent reviews to mitigate conflicts and maintain fiduciary accountability. Changes to application procedures could therefore influence how organisations approach plan governance and service provider relationships.
An example: funding through a captive
Employers often establish captives to fund property and casualty risks or medical stop-loss coverage using feasibility studies to assess potential savings and financial requirements. After gaining experience managing a captive, some explore additional opportunities to fund employee benefits.
Employers sponsoring ERISA plans are parties in interest to those plans. Entities in which an employer holds a 50% or greater interest, including captives, generally share that status. Using a captive to reinsure ERISA-covered benefits, such as group life, disability or pension benefits therefore constitutes a prohibited transaction unless an existing exemption applies or the employer obtains a new one.
The DOL has historically granted exemptions for these arrangements. Since 2001, most captive reinsurance relief was approved through EXPRO rather than full individual exemption applications, although EXPRO filings have largely ceased since 2017.
For employers considering captive-funded benefits, understanding the exemption process, including its timeline, costs and documentation requirements, is an important part of evaluating feasibility. Experienced advisers can help organisations assess opportunities and navigate regulatory requirements.
What could change
Before the 2020s, the last substantial revision to the exemption regulation dated to 2011. EBSA proposed significant updates in 2022, which were finalised in 2024 and applied to applications filed on or after April 8, 2024.
Industry participants viewed the 2024 changes as increasing the cost and complexity of obtaining exemptions, potentially discouraging applications and favouring organisations with greater resources.
The DOL now intends to streamline the process. Although proposed amendments remain unavailable, potential areas for review include application requirements, documentation expectations and procedural steps introduced in 2024.
A more efficient process could improve clarity and accessibility for applicants. However, any revisions should also be evaluated for their effects on transparency, regulatory oversight and participant protections.
Why this matters
Simplifying the exemption process could allow more organisations to pursue relief and explore employee benefit funding strategies. Increased participation could also encourage competition among service providers and reduce the costs associated with obtaining exemptions.
For captive arrangements, potential savings must be evaluated alongside applicable participant protections, including requirements to pass through at least 51% of savings to plan participants and beneficiaries. Regardless of procedural changes, strong fiduciary oversight remains essential to protecting participants and maintaining ERISA compliance.
What this means for employers
Although proposed amendments have not been released, employers and fiduciaries can prepare by:
Monitoring regulatory developments: Follow DOL guidance and proposed rule-making for potential implications.
Reviewing governance practices: Ensure committee structures, fiduciary processes and policies are current, documented and consistently followed.
Evaluating service provider relationships: Understand how potential changes could affect existing arrangements and responsibilities.
Documenting decisions: Maintain records demonstrating prudent fiduciary oversight.
Consulting experienced advisers: Work with benefits professionals and ERISA counsel to assess compliance obligations and emerging opportunities.
ERISA continues to require fiduciaries to act prudently and solely in the interests of plan participants and beneficiaries. Strong governance practices will help organisations adapt as regulatory guidance evolves.
Questions employers should be asking now
- Employers can begin evaluating their readiness by asking:
- Are our fiduciary governance processes documented and consistently followed?
- Have we reviewed our relationships with investment managers, advisers, record-keepers and other service providers?
- Did we previously set aside a captive-funded benefit arrangement because of the exemption process, and would a streamlined process change that assessment?
- Do we understand potential conflicts of interest within our benefit plans?
- Are we monitoring regulatory developments and prepared to adapt our policies if requirements change?
Addressing these questions now can strengthen oversight and help organisations evaluate future opportunities.
Looking ahead
Once proposed amendments are released, stakeholders will have an opportunity to review and comment before final regulations are adopted. Because regulatory priorities can change between administrations, employers should establish durable governance practices rather than rely on any single regulatory framework.
Spring Consulting Group’s retirement consulting team can help employers evaluate fiduciary governance, compliance considerations and employee benefit funding strategies as the regulatory landscape evolves.
Read the full article on the Spring Consulting Group website springgroup.com:
Navigating DOL Changes: Considerations for Employers and Fiduciaries
Sources
US Department of Labor: Employee Benefits Security Administration Regulatory Agenda
US Department of Labor: Exemption Procedures Under ERISA
US Department of Labor: Prohibited Transaction Exemptions
Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs: Unified Regulatory Agenda
Prabal Lakhanpal is senior vice president at Spring Consulting Group. He can be contacted at: prabal.lakhanpal@springgroup.com
Karin Landry is senior consultant and co-founder of Spring Consulting Group. She can be contacted at: karin.landry@springgroup.com
Did you get value from this story? Sign up to our free newsletters and get stories like this sent straight to your inbox.
