Shutterstock.com_1141202039/Tony Stock
20 November 2026Analysis

Transfer pricing: can your captive show Its working?

Sumit Bagla (pictured), of Capitawise, looks at recent developments in transfer pricing reviews and the latest legal cases.

Captive insurance has always sat close to the tax line, and transfer pricing scrutiny of it has only intensified. That holds for captives of every size, not just the small 831(b) structures that make the headlines. 

Tax authorities around the world, guided by the OECD’s work on profit shifting and backed by increasingly well-resourced revenue services, are looking harder at whether intra-group insurance is genuine, backed by real substance and priced the way two unrelated parties would have priced it. Transfer pricing rules apply to a global manufacturer’s captive reinsurer just as squarely as to a family business’s micro-captive.

For any captive owner, the central question is deceptively simple: would the premium your captive charges stand up to a transfer pricing review and, if asked, could you show your working? It is a question that rewards attention long before anyone official comes knocking.

What the cases tell us

The case law reaches far beyond the smallest arrangements, and it cuts both ways. In the US, the long-running UPS v. Commissioner dispute centred on the excess-value charges United Parcel Service routed through Overseas Partners, a Bermuda affiliate. The Tax Court sided with the IRS in 1999 and added penalties. The Eleventh Circuit reversed the judgment in 2001, holding that the arrangement had real economic substance and a genuine business purpose. UPS won, but only after years of litigation and paying $1.8 billion into a special account with the IRS while the appeal was pending.

Across the Atlantic, the landmark UK case DSG Retail v HMRC concerned the captive of Britain’s largest electrical retailer, the group behind Dixons, Currys and PC World. HMRC successfully challenged the pricing of an intra-group insurance arrangement on transfer-pricing grounds.

In Belgium, a Ghent Court judgment of 6 June 2025 looked at a Swiss captive reinsurer covering only intra-group risks. The tax administration argued it was little more than an administrative shell: no staff, outsourced management, investments largely within the group and too little financial capacity for an independent insurer to choose it. The court found for the taxpayer and placed the burden on the authority to prove the premiums failed the transfer pricing test. The lesson advisers have drawn is not that captives are safe, but that owners should have strong support and documentation ready.

At the smaller end, the US Tax Court held, in Jones v. Commissioner, in a memorandum opinion of 29 September 2026, that premiums were not negotiated at arm’s length, the core test in any transfer pricing review. It sustained 40% accuracy-related penalties, enhanced from the usual 20% because the transaction had not been adequately disclosed.

The common thread across jurisdictions and captive sizes is evidence. Where premiums cannot be shown to reflect what independent parties would have agreed, deductions are challenged, profits are reallocated, and penalties can follow. Where an owner can show the substance and the working, even a determined challenge can fail, though rarely quickly or cheaply.

From an annual check to a continuous review

For most captives, transfer pricing evidence is still assembled once a year, or only when someone asks for it. The data lives in scattered loss runs, spreadsheets and actuarial reports, and pulling it together under pressure is slow and error-prone. By the time a weak spot is found, several years of premiums might already be exposed.

Technology now makes a different approach possible. When a captive’s claims, premium and balance-sheet data sit together in one governed place, its pricing can be reviewed continuously rather than annually. AI can do the heavy lifting: analysing loss experience line of coverage by line of coverage as new data arrives, testing it against the premium charged, and explaining the result in plain English.

The key is transparency. A transfer pricing review is only useful if every figure can be traced back to its source and every step of the calculation can be shown, because that is exactly what a tax authority will test. Done well, this turns transfer pricing from a reactive defence into an ongoing discipline: weak spots surface early, while there is still time to fix them, instead of in the middle of an audit.

Putting it into practice

At Capitawise, we saw this shift coming and have built it into our platform. We already provide captives with a governed, AI-enabled platform for the captive scorecard, reserving, capital adequacy and surplus management. Our Transfer Pricing Review now sits alongside those tools as a risk-mitigation measure, helping captives produce the right evidence when it is asked for.

It looks at a captive’s own loss experience, line of coverage by line of coverage, and gives a plain-English read on how well the evidence supports the premium charged. The full calculation is shown, every figure traces back to its source, and because the review shares a platform with the captive’s reserving, capital and surplus data, the pricing story and the balance-sheet story stay consistent.

The output is framed as a prompt to discuss with your adviser, not a verdict. It is deliberately not tax nor legal advice, and it does not pretend to settle a topic this nuanced. We believe we are among the first to bring this into software, and see it as the start of a conversation, not the end of one.

The captives that come through scrutiny well will be the ones that can show their working on demand. We have written more about how the review works, and the safeguards built into it, at capitawise.ai/blog/transfer-pricing-review-captives, and we would welcome the chance to walk you through it.

About the author

Sumit Bagla drives technology strategy at Capitawise. Learn more at capitawise.ai.

Did you get value from this story?  Sign up to our free newsletters and get stories like this sent straight to your inbox.