Collateral: Why do I need it?

Jeremy Colombik (pictured) of Management Services International explains why collateral is so fundamental to captive insurance companies.

Collateral is a fundamental component when using a captive insurance company to insure the risks of your business. It can act in the capacity very much like a financial guarantee that ensures claims will be paid, which provides stability and credibility to your captive insurance company. 

Understanding the importance of collateral is essential for businesses considering or managing a captive, as it impacts the regulatory compliance, financial security, and the long-term success of your captive insurance company. 

Collateral in a captive insurance company typically refers to a financial reserve such as cash, a letter of credit, or a trust agreement funded with cash or securities that secures the captive’s ability to pay any claims. Unlike traditional insurance where the insurer assumes risk a captive is owned by the insured themselves as they typically operate the insured company. Collateral ensures that if the captive does not have sufficient funds to cover claims, there is a backstop to protect claimants, and the fronting carrier involved in the insurance arrangement. 

Why is collateral so important in a captive? 

Regulatory and Financial Compliance 

Captive insurance companies must meet specific regulatory capital and financial responsibility requirements. Collateral can help satisfy these requirements by formalizing the funds set aside to pay for future claims. This capitalization is critical to maintaining the captives license and operational viability to help ensure solvency. 

Support for a Fronting Carrier 

Utilizing A fronting carrier is becoming more popular with captives. The fronting carrier may have the required admitted paper and back-office support to issue the policies. The fronting carrier bears the credit risk and requires collateral so that it can be assured all claims will be paid. Posting collateral acts as a security for the fronting carrier protecting them in case the captive cannot fulfill its claim obligations. This arrangement helps to align the interest of both parties and is often mandated in a fronting agreement. 

Claims Payments and Program Stability 

Collateral is a way that’s helps ensure that claims will be paid even if the captive does not have the financial solvency or runs into financial difficulties. This form of financial backing keeps the captive program stable and credible which is vital for attracting reinsurers and maintaining the trust with the fronting carrier and the captive members. 

Protecting Member Interests 

In Group captives collateral also serves to protect all the members from each other's 

potential bad debts. For example, if a member were to incur losses and then leaves the captive without paying their share the collateral can cover those claims preventing other members from bearing the cost. This mutual protection is essential for the cooperative nature of group captives. 

Different forms and Management of Collateral. 

Collateral can be posted through various forms, including; 

Cash Reserves: This provides liquidity and earns interest but can tie up any working capital a company may need. 

Letter of Credit: This does not require an immediate outlay of cash but can be costly and harder to obtain. 

Trust Agreements: These are funded by securities and managed by a trustee, offering a balance between liquidity and security. 

Captive owners often work with both the fronting carrier and the regulators to decide which form and amount the collateral should be. The required collateral varies based on the type of risk insured the line of business insured and the claims history of the insured. Over time as the captive starts to build up a surplus and demonstrates good claims history as well as solvency it may be able to start to reduce the amount of collateral required. 

The Costs and Benefits of Collateral 

While collateral is often a necessary component of captive insurance it represents a financial cost and capital commitment for the owners of the captive. Posting collateral can tie up funds that might otherwise be used in the business and obtaining a letter of credit can be expensive or difficult to obtain. 

However, the benefits often outweigh these costs for many businesses: 

Financial Security: collateral ensures the captive can meet its obligations while reducing the risk to the fronting carrier. 

Regulatory Compliance: Collateral is a must to maintain good standing with both the fronting carrier and the regulators to avoid penalties or being put under review to determine solvency. 

Improved Risk Management: Posting collateral can spur on better risk management, safety and claims practices to avoid needing to rely on the collateral to make claims payments. 

Potential to Capture Underwriting Profit: As the captive starts to mature and claims history starts to become more predictable, excess collateral can start to be released over time and the captive owners can start to realize their profits from their risk management program. 

Holding and Releasing Collateral 

Collateral can be held for several years after the policy closes to cover reserves and incurred, but not reported, claims. Depending on the type of policy written collateral can be held up to seven years or even more depending upon the nature of the risk. This delay in releasing collateral can become very frustrating for businesses who are looking to exit a captive if it is necessary make sure all claims are fully settled to make the exit as smooth and quick as possible. 

Good captive performance and effective risk management strategies can speed up the return of unused collateral rewarding owners as they can start to take profits from their captive. 

Collateral is an essential piece of a captive insurance arrangement. It provides the financial foundation that supports regulatory compliance protects the fronting carriers and ensures claim payments. Even though collateral requires a capital commitment and it can represent an additional cost it is an indispensable piece when looking to maintain the stability credibility and long term success of the captive insurance program. Businesses who are considering a captive arrangement should carefully evaluate the collateral requirements and work with experienced advisors to make sure their captives structure and financial strategy are in line.

Did you get value from this story?  Sign up to our free daily newsletters and get stories like this sent straight to your inbox.