Medical stop loss cover essential in US

Andrea Valacchi (pictured), director EMEA at Generali Employee Benefits, looks at the purpose, objectives and benefits of medical stop loss insurance in an international captive programme.

A few weeks ago, I was reminded of the considerable expenses tied at times to healthcare plans in the US, when a client shared details of a substantial medical claim.

The case involved a premature baby with heart complications requiring months of intensive care, resulting in a staggering total cost of $10 million. While the survival of the child was a relief, the financial implications of such claims underscore the need for robust risk management solutions for self-insured employers.

Medical stop loss insurance offers a critical financial safeguard in this context. By capping financial exposure to catastrophic individual claims, it allows employers to offer comprehensive healthcare benefits while maintaining budget stability. For multinational organisations, integrating medical stop loss coverage into an international captive programme enhances risk management, optimises costs and provides greater flexibility.

This article explores the purpose and benefits of stop loss insurance and examines the advantages of incorporating it into an international captive programme.

Purpose and role of medical stop loss insurance

In the US, self-insured employers bear the responsibility of funding employee medical expenses directly. This approach offers greater control but exposes organisations to the risk of unpredictable, high-cost individual claims. Medical stop loss insurance mitigates these risks by capping financial liability, ensuring that catastrophic claims do not destabilise budgets.

Stop loss insurance operates at two levels. Specific stop loss limits the financial impact of high-cost claims from individual employees, while aggregate stop loss caps total claims across the utilisation of the entire workforce. Together, these mechanisms support predictable budgeting and enable organisations to provide robust healthcare benefits without jeopardising financial stability.

Challenges in the US healthcare system

The US healthcare landscape presents unique challenges that make medical stop loss coverage indispensable. Rising costs driven by advanced medical technologies, specialty drugs and chronic disease prevalence increase employers’ financial exposure. Chronic illnesses such as diabetes and cancer lead to recurring high-cost claims, further straining resources.

Additionally, employers face significant challenges navigating a complex regulatory environment characterised by varying state and federal healthcare laws. This complexity adds layers of difficulty for organisations operating across multiple jurisdictions. The volatility of high-cost claims and regional disparities in healthcare expenses compound the problem, making effective risk management a necessity.

Captive insurance: a strategic risk management tool

Captive insurance offers organisations an alternative way to manage risks by creating their own insurance entity. This approach centralises risk management, allowing for tailored coverage, improved oversight and cost efficiency. For multinational organisations, captives provide a framework to consolidate healthcare risk management alongside other operational risks, aligning with broader financial and strategic objectives.

Integrating medical stop loss insurance into an international captive programme offers several advantages. Organisations can retain underwriting profits that would otherwise go to traditional insurers, optimise coverage terms to suit specific needs and use detailed claims data to implement proactive risk management measures. Captives also create a financial buffer by accumulating reserves, which can be reinvested in initiatives that reduce long-term healthcare costs.

Benefits of combining medical stop loss insurance and captives

In addition to bringing cost efficiencies that are not negligible in consideration of budgets involved, this approach also offers customisation of liability caps, enabling captives to adjust coverage triggering thresholds and options based on workforce demographics and claims history.

Beyond financial benefits, captives improve overall risk management. Access to detailed claims data allows organisations to identify trends, predict high-cost claims and implement preventive measures. By spreading risks across time and geographies, captives reduce the volatility associated with large claims, contributing to financial stability.

Portfolio diversification is also not to be disregarded as important benefit. By “pooling” different types of risks, the captive can reduce the overall experience volatility lessening the dependency on external insurers for high-cost claims, allowing a captive to retain more control over its risk management strategy. Captives can also efficiently use their capital by retaining predictable risks, investing retained capital to generate income, negotiating better terms with reinsurers to protect their capital from large, infrequent losses.

Captive programmes also align with broader organisational goals, including environmental, social, and governance (ESG) initiatives. For example, funds retained within captives can support wellness programmes and preventive healthcare measures, enhancing employee wellbeing while reducing costs over time.

Incorporating medical stop-loss insurance into a captive programme not only strengthens an organisation’s financial resilience but also fosters a proactive, data-driven approach to healthcare risk management. This dual benefit of cost savings and enhanced risk mitigation makes the strategy especially attractive for multinational companies aiming for sustainable growth and stability in an ever-evolving healthcare landscape.

Incorporating medical stop loss insurance into a captive programme not only fortifies an organisation's financial resilience but also promotes a proactive, data-driven approach to healthcare risk management. This dual benefit of cost savings and enhanced risk mitigation makes the strategy particularly appealing for multinational companies seeking sustainable growth and stability in an ever-evolving healthcare landscape.

Implementation considerations

To integrate medical stop loss insurance into a captive programme successfully, organisations need to conduct actuarial analyses to determine adequate thresholds and select an appropriate domicile with favourable regulatory and tax environments. It is essential to ensure the captive has the operational capacity to manage healthcare claims effectively and engage key stakeholders to align objectives. Addressing compliance requirements in each jurisdiction is also critical to smooth implementation.

Conclusion

Medical stop loss insurance is an essential risk management tool for self-insured employers, particularly in the U.S. By limiting financial exposure to individual catastrophic claims, it supports budget predictability and enables organisations to offer robust healthcare benefits. Integrating this coverage into an international captive programme amplifies these benefits, offering cost efficiency, customisation and enhanced risk management.

For multinational organisations, captive programmes provide a centralised and flexible approach to managing healthcare risks alongside other liabilities. As the challenges of the US healthcare system continue to evolve, the combination of stop loss insurance and captive solutions will remain an effective strategy for safeguarding financial stability, supporting employee health and driving sustainable organisational growth.

Andrea Valacchi is director EMEA at Generali Employee Benefits. He can be contacted at: valacchi@geb.com

Did you get value from this story?  Sign up to our free daily newsletters and get stories like this sent straight to your inbox.