13 December 2018Accounting & tax analysis

831(b) captive conspiracy lawsuit has no merit, claims Gallagher


Arthur J Gallagher has hit back at the Arizona-based lawsuit accusing it and its subsidiary Artex Risk Solutions of selling and managing illegal tax-advantaged captives, the firm said in a statement.

"Gallagher and Artex are aware of the recent filing of a class action lawsuit relating to our 831(b) captive business," the statement read. "We have disclosed the ongoing IRS audit and related customer litigation involving our 831(b) captive management business in our SEC filings and to our clients. This class action lawsuit appears to be related to the IRS audit. We believe it has no merit and will deal with it accordingly."

The case, Shivkov v Artex Risk Solutions, was filed in the US District Court for the District of Arizona - Phoenix Division. The complaint alleges that Gallagher and Artex had disguised tax shelters as legitimate 831(b) captives and extracted money from their clients.

Furthermore, the suit also alleges that the defendants had entered into undisclosed, illegal business arrangements with each other and a nationwide referral network of investment, accounting, and legal advisors to refer clients to them.

Gallagher added that the firm, along with Artex, have successfully defended individual claims involving similar allegations.

"831(b) captives are important insurance vehicles that have been part of the Internal Revenue’s code for decades," the statement continued. "Gallagher and Artex have diligently and consistently striven to comply with the legal requirements in forming and managing captive insurance companies."

For the full story on the lawsuit,  click here.


More on this story

Accounting & tax analysis
17 December 2018   Captive managers and promoters including Gallagher and Artex have come under fire for allegedly conspiring to sell and manage illegal tax shelter captive insurance strategies. Matthew Queen, general counsel & chief compliance officer at Venture Captive Management, provides some insight into the lawsuit.
Accounting & tax analysis
28 January 2019   The Arizona-based lawsuit Shivkov v Artex Risk Solutions is being followed with great interest by the captive insurance industry, perhaps with good reason. One of the lead lawyers involved in the case now claims the alleged conspiracy is larger than it seems. He explained why to Captive International.
Accounting & tax analysis
10 December 2018   An Arizona-based lawsuit is seeking damages from a group of defendants including Artex Risk Solutions, Arthur J Gallagher among other captive service providers for conspiring to design, promote, sell, implement and manage illegal tax-advantaged captive insurance strategies using unlawful attempted 831(b) elections.

More on this story

Accounting & tax analysis
17 December 2018   Captive managers and promoters including Gallagher and Artex have come under fire for allegedly conspiring to sell and manage illegal tax shelter captive insurance strategies. Matthew Queen, general counsel & chief compliance officer at Venture Captive Management, provides some insight into the lawsuit.
Accounting & tax analysis
28 January 2019   The Arizona-based lawsuit Shivkov v Artex Risk Solutions is being followed with great interest by the captive insurance industry, perhaps with good reason. One of the lead lawyers involved in the case now claims the alleged conspiracy is larger than it seems. He explained why to Captive International.
Accounting & tax analysis
10 December 2018   An Arizona-based lawsuit is seeking damages from a group of defendants including Artex Risk Solutions, Arthur J Gallagher among other captive service providers for conspiring to design, promote, sell, implement and manage illegal tax-advantaged captive insurance strategies using unlawful attempted 831(b) elections.